Custom cookies for life’s sweetest stories.

Shop Now

Decorated cookies in a clear box with a red background. One cookie reads 'Back to School' and the other is an apple with the name 'Oliver' and a worm with glasses.

Decorative cookies with school and gardening themes, decorated with colorful icing and markers, placed on black and patterned papers, in front of Crayola markers.

A decorative apple-shaped item with the word 'Teacher' written on it in yellow, green, brown, and red colors, placed on a polka dot surface with yellow and red accents.

Colorful birthday cookies with various designs, including birthday messages, age numbers, and a party hat, arranged on a wooden cutting board on a marble surface.

Decorated cookies with American flag theme, featuring red, white, and blue colors, stars, stripes, and the words 'U.S.' on some cookies, arranged on a wooden surface.

Colorful cookies shaped like words spelling out 'LOVE' with various classroom supplies around them, including pens and markers on a black surface.

Available Cookie Sets

Happy Birthday Cookie Set

$30.00

Celebrate their special day with a set of 6 personalized birthday sugar cookies! Customize the name and age, and choose from two festive color options: a Blue Palette or a Purple & Orange Palette. Perfect for birthday celebrations, party tables, or gifting!

Color:

Back to School with Love Cookie Set

$25.00

A little love for their next big adventure! This sweet set of 4 Back to School sugar cookies spells out LOVE with playful school-inspired details, the perfect treat for celebrating a brand-new chapter and making the first day a little sweeter.

Custom Cookies

Customizable Birthday Cookie Sets

Make their birthday a little sweeter with a cookie set made just for them! Our Customizable Birthday Cookie Sets are thoughtfully designed to celebrate their special day with personalized details like names, ages, and colors because every birthday is a story worth celebrating, with a little extra sugar, of course!

Special Occasion Cookie Sets

From baby showers and weddings to anniversaries, graduations, and every special moment in between, our custom cookies are made to celebrate your story. Each set is thoughtfully designed and handcrafted just for your occasion, creating a sweet and memorable detail that looks almost too good to eat. Whatever you’re celebrating, let us help make it a little sweeter one cookie at a time.

Holiday Cookie Sets

Celebrate the season with cookies made to share! Our Holiday Cookie Sets are thoughtfully designed to make every festive moment a little sweeter, from Valentine's Day and Easter to Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas, and everything in between. Because every holiday is a story worth celebrating with a little extra sugar, of course!

At Stories in Sugar, every cookie has a story to tell! From birthdays and baby showers to weddings, holidays, milestones, and just-because moments, each cookie is handcrafted with care and designed especially for you.

Because the sweetest moments deserve a little extra sugar, we create custom cookies that feel personal, beautiful, and almost too pretty to eat. Whatever chapter you’re celebrating, we can’t wait to help make it a little sweeter, one cookie, one celebration, and one sweet story at a time.

Curated Taste, Timeless Craft

Follow Our Journey

Set of six light blue and white birthday cookies on a cooling rack, decorated with balloons, a hat, a candle, and birthday messages.

Decorated cookies with soccer and sports themes on green grass background, including soccer balls, goal nets, and cleats with the number 8.

Cookies decorated with American flag-themed patriotic designs, including red, white, and blue colors, stars, and stripes, arranged on a cooling rack.

Explore

Request a Custom Order

A woman with blonde hair in a black sleeveless top standing in a modern kitchen, smiling at the camera, with a stand mixer on the counter.